How to Replace Your Retention Stack: Line-Item Costs for Recharge, Klaviyo, Gorgias, Rebuy and GRIN

Ryan Cooper

Subscriptions Solutions Lead, Chargezen

Oct 9, 2026 · 2 min read

Disclosure: Chargezen sells a platform that replaces several of these tools. Prices come from each vendor's public pricing page, without negotiated discounts. The Recharge price was rechecked on November 3, 2026; the other rows were checked on October 9, 2026, so check them again before you compare.

A typical Shopify subscription brand runs five separate tools: subscriptions, email and SMS, customer support, upsells, and creator marketing. Each one bills on a different meter. This example prices them for one brand so you can swap in your own numbers.

The example brand

  • 5,000 subscription orders a month at a $50 average order value
  • 2,000 support tickets a month
  • A creator program on a mid-tier plan

Line-item costs

JobTool and planHow it billsMonthly cost
SubscriptionsRecharge Scale$499/mo + 1.25% + $0.20 per transaction$4,624
Email and SMSKlaviyoBy active profiles and message volumeUse Klaviyo's calculator
Customer supportGorgias Pro, annual$300/mo for 2,000 tickets; AI Agent $0.90 per resolution$300 + AI resolutions
UpsellsRebuy Platform OneFrom $534/mo billed monthly, priced by ordersFrom $534
Creator marketingGRIN Growth$500/mo with 7,500 credits$500
Recharge alone is about $4,624 a month, or $55,488 a year, at this volume (checked November 3, 2026), because its fee grows with every order. Add the other rows at your own volume and plan.

See what you could save by moving to Chargezen

Pick your current plan and enter your numbers. The result updates as you type.

$
$

Add it to see how many months of product work the savings would cover.

Yearly savings with Chargezen Subscriptions

$53,498

Recharge Scale, per year
$55,488
Chargezen Subscriptions, per year
$1,990
Difference per year
$53,498

About $4,458 more a month for Meta ads ($53,498 a year).

$53,498 a year toward product development.

How we calculate it: 12 × (base price + orders × (average order × percentage fee + per-order fee)), using your average order value for every order. Chargezen Subscriptions is counted at its Shopify Plus price, $1,990 a year, or $199 a month billed monthly, with no commission or per-order fee. On Shopify Advanced it is $990 a year, so you save more.

Skio charges its fee on the whole total of any order that includes a subscription, including one-time items, shipping and tax, after discounts. Recharge charges its fee on every transaction it processes. Your real bill can be higher or lower.

Chargezen Subscriptions is for Shopify Advanced and Shopify Plus stores. Messaging and Services cost extra. Payment processing fees are separate and stay the same when you switch. Prices checked November 3, 2026: Recharge pricing, Skio pricing, Chargezen pricing.

What one platform costs for the same jobs

JobChargezen productPrice
SubscriptionsSubscriptions on Shopify Plus$199/mo, or $1,990/yr ($99/mo on Advanced)
Email and SMSSmartyTap Pro (25,000 contacts)$199/mo, or $1,990/yr
Creator marketingSpark! Pro$199/mo, or $1,990/yr
Customer supportConcierge Pro (199,000 credits)$199/mo, or $1,990/yr
UpsellsCheckoutOS Pro$99/mo
About $895 a month for a Shopify Plus store, or $9,148 a year with the $199 plans billed annually. On Shopify Advanced, Subscriptions is $99 a month. Smaller brands can start SmartyTap, Concierge and CheckoutOS at $20 a month, and Spark! at $99. Usage such as SMS, email volume and AI outcomes is billed separately (Chargezen pricing).

What the comparison leaves out

  • Features are not identical: Each specialist tool goes deep in its category. List the features you rely on and check each one before you move.
  • Usage costs exist on both sides: SMS, email volume and AI resolutions cost money on any platform. Compare them with your own volumes.
  • Switching takes work: Plan the move one tool at a time, starting with the one whose cost grows fastest. For subscriptions, see our migration guide.

Run your own numbers

Start with the line that scales with revenue. Use the Recharge cost calculator for your subscription fees, then add each tool's plan at your volume. For a wider look at subscription apps, see Shopify subscription apps with no transaction fees.

Written by

Ryan Cooper

Subscriptions Solutions Lead, Chargezen

Ryan leads subscriptions solutions at Chargezen, and writes about the systems and strategies behind modern subscription businesses. His writing explores recurring billing, subscription lifecycle management, payment recovery, pricing optimization, and the role of AI in revenue operations. He focuses on the practical challenges businesses face as they scale recurring revenue, from reducing involuntary churn and managing complex billing workflows to building more efficient systems for monetization.

Ready to Grow Your Subscription Revenue?

Join leading brands using Chargezen to reduce churn, increase revenue, and automate operations.

Get Started
Space, at your fingertips

What would you do with 22% more revenue?